Gayton McKenzie says sorry to Tatjana Smith, launches attack on Swimming SA

Sports Minister Gayton McKenzie has ordered a full investigation into Swimming South Africa (SSA) following Olympic champion Tatjana Smith’s decision to pursue her swimming career under the Dutch flag.

McKenzie also issued a public apology to Smith, accusing the national swimming federation of treating one of South Africa’s greatest sporting champions disgracefully.

READ | Roland Schoeman blasts Swimming SA after Tatjana Smith’s shock Netherlands switch

Speaking at a media briefing at Parliament on Tuesday, 17 November, Gayton McKenzie said he had lost complete faith in Swimming SA and believed the federation needed urgent intervention.

Smith shocked South African sport last week when she announced that she intended to represent the Netherlands, following growing tensions with Swimming SA over sponsorship arrangements, fines and prize money.

READ | THIRD South African Olympic swimmer to pursue career under another flag

Gayton McKenzie said he had no ill feelings towards the swimmer for her decision, arguing that the federation’s treatment of her had contributed to her departure.

“She’s been treated in the worst possible way. They should be ashamed.

“And what angered me the most is that immediately after we got the news that Tatjana is going to swim for the Netherlands, they tried to cover up and make her the scapegoat,” he said.

€46 000 penalty and withheld prize money

Gayton McKenzie highlighted Smith’s lengthy battle to receive money owed to her following her performances at the 2023 World Championships in Fukuoka, Japan.

According to the minister, Smith was invoiced €46 000 for an alleged sponsorship infringement after she failed to wear a particular sponsor’s brand.

Swimming SA subsequently withheld her prize money, resulting in a prolonged dispute over payment.

McKenzie said Smith only received the money in 2024 after instructing her lawyers to pursue legal action.

The minister also said his department had ensured that all money owed to the swimmer by the department was paid without delay.

“We paid her as fast as she swims. We want to thank her for the years that she’s given, for the medals that she’s given us, for what she’s done for this country,” he said.

Gayton McKenzie described Smith as South Africa’s greatest Olympian and said she deserved an apology for the way she had been treated.

SASCOC given 90 days to investigate Swimming SA

McKenzie has written to the South African Sports Confederation and Olympic Committee (SASCOC), requesting a full investigation into Swimming SA’s administration and financial affairs.

The investigation will examine the federation’s sponsorship agreement with Arena, including the penalties imposed on athletes and who was responsible for paying them.

McKenzie also wants investigators to establish whether other swimmers have been fined or had prize money withheld.

However, the investigation will extend beyond the sponsorship dispute.

The minister said SASCOC had also been asked to examine how money was spent on the Franschhoek High-Performance Centre and identify alleged shortcomings in Swimming SA’s constitution.

He believes Smith may have been made a scapegoat for broader administrative problems within the federation.

“I’ve asked it to establish how the Arena sponsorship agreement works, what penalties were levied and who paid them, and whether other swimmers were fined or had money held back.

“I’ve asked it to look at how money was spent on the Franschhoek High-Performance Centre and the flaws in the federation’s constitution. And that’s why our swimmers are choosing to represent other countries,” McKenzie said.

SASCOC’s acting head, Lwandile Simelane, has pledged to complete the investigation within 90 days.

McKenzie said regulations require SASCOC to deal with the matter first, making its investigation an important initial step before further action can be considered.

McKenzie says Swimming SA needs urgent intervention

The minister has also called for a task team to help stabilise the federation, describing its current condition in particularly strong terms.

“I’ve asked SASCOC to deploy a task team to stabilise the federation, because the federation is in ICU. And we should not run away from that,” he said.

McKenzie warned that Smith should be the last South African athlete to experience such treatment from a national sporting federation.

“But I want to assure South Africans that she’s the last athlete who will be treated in such a fashion by these federations. That is not how a national federation should treat the people it exists to serve,” he said.

Tatjana Smith’s departure raises questions about South African swimming

Smith won Olympic gold in the 200m breaststroke at Tokyo 2020 and silver in the same event at Paris 2024.

Her decision to pursue representation by the Netherlands has raised wider questions about athlete welfare, funding and the administration of South African sporting federations.

McKenzie’s intervention now places Swimming SA’s sponsorship arrangements, financial management and governance under scrutiny.

The outcome of the 90-day SASCOC investigation could prove significant for the federation and the future of South African swimming.

For now, McKenzie has made his position clear: he believes Smith deserved better and wants those responsible for the federation’s administration to answer questions about how it operates.